Your Fertility Appointment Today to Start Your Family Tomorrow


You are here

Successful Outcomes with Natural Cycle IVF

a blog by Dr. Michael DiMattina, Dominion Fertility, July 9, 2014

Dominion Fertility began offering Natural Cycle IVF (NCIVF) in January, 2007, and to date we have performed more than 3,000 cycles of NCIVF, the largest experience in the United States and one of the largest NCIVF programs in the world.

This week, the Journal of Reproductive Medicine published our experience describing critical parameters necessary in order to optimize a successful treatment outcome using NCIVF (J Reprod Med 2014;59:267-273). This data will assist other IVF centers interested in starting a NCIVF program or enhance the results in centers that already offer NCIVF.

We described certain critical parameters in estrogen levels and follicle sizes that resulted in better pregnancy rates in 422 patients who underwent 821 cycles of NCIVF from 2007-2010. Furthermore, we found that FSH and antimullerian hormone (AMH) levels were irrelevant in predicting NCIVF success. In other words, the pregnancy rates were not diminished in patients who's FSH levels were greater than 10 or in those patients with low AMH levels. Poor ovarian reserve did not lower the success rates in patients treated with NCIVF.

In this group of patients we found the clinical success rates for NCIVF were similar on day 3 or 5 embryo transfer. In stimulated IVF, it is well established that a day 5 embryo transfer is superior to a day 3 transfer. Because there is no ovarian stimulation in NCIVF, the endometrium is spared the well-demonstrated adverse effects of ovarian stimulation drugs on the endometrium, and that is why we believe we observed no differences in day 3 or 5 embryo transfer using NCIVF.

Most importantly, our live birth rates or ongoing pregnancies per transfer rate were 49%, 24%, 27% and 13% for patients under 30, 31-34, 35-39, 40-42 years old, respectively, again unaffected by the level of the patients' FSH or AMH level. In fact, about one third of these patients had poor ovarian reserve.

In 2009, we began offering NCIVF to all patients with regular menstrual cycles regardless of their FSH or AMH levels or their history of previous failures using stimulated IVF. Anecdotally, we had a 48 year old nulliparous patient deliver a healthy infant following her first embryo transfer using NCIVF with her own egg. This patient's FSH was 20 and her AMH 0.6.

For many years NCIVF was considered of historical interest only. The concern with NCIVF has focused on the lower success rates and the need for multiple treatment cycles to achieve the same pregnancy rates as a single treatment cycle of stimulated IVF. This concern seems less relevant today with modern IVF techniques such as careful ultrasound and estradiol assessments to determine follicular competence and maturity. Indeed, in this study, 84% of our pregnancies occurred within the first 2 embryo transfers, so most did not require more than 2 embryo transfers.

We believe that NCIVF if an effective and well-received therapy for any infertile patient with regular menstrual cycles regardless of their ovarian reserve. I look forward to sharing with you more information on our next article coming out this month further describing another 1,200 cycles of NCIVF at Dominion Fertility that directly compares the success rates of NCIVF to that of stimulated IVF. Stay tuned! Dr. Michael DiMattina

Comments (4)

Hi Gretchen, I can do research on your behalf and give you one or two doctor options in your area to choose from. Please email me at with the following information; Name, Age, Months TTC, Zip Code & if you have health insurance; as well as any other relevant history that you think could be helpful. Happy to help and looking forward to hearing back, Jenna

There is little risk of premature ovulation during natural cycle. The doctor should well guess based on the size of the follicle and the estradiol level of the blood whether the egg is almost ready to ripen. It just happened with me recently that I started ovulating before aspiration, and then, when the follicle lost some fluid nobody can say for sure via ultrasound that the egg itself is still in there. Would it be possible to perform immediate egg aspiration, if the egg is overly mature (cca 2x2mms for 2 consecutive days) already and seems necessary, during monitoring hours the day before the scheduled procedure?

Hi Susan, Has the clinic given you feedback or a call to discuss results? Usually mid afternoon or towards the evening clinics follow up with patients to discuss monitoring results. We are not doctors nor can we provide you with medical advice. Please follow up with your doctor. Thank you Bhavi

I live in the Boston area, are there any clinics that do NCIVF in New England?

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.